I've read all the arguements and I've read the rules but what matters is that in real life the ball is virtually always replaced as it's impossible to know whether someone has purposely fouled or not,so in practice we don't need a mod/supercomputer to say whether a player has cheatedor not,so we might as well have something as close to the real thing as possible,or at least closer than what we have now which is a ridiculous rule that isn't played at all in real snooker.
the ball should be replaced whenever someone fouls
Posted in
Billiards
the ball should be replaced whenever someone fouls
These are the real international rules if I'm not mistaken. This is as close to the "real" thing as you will get. Snipe
The miss only applies to professionals or when chosen by local competitions. This game fits into neither catagory.
the miss rule is allways played as it is a standered rule of snooker and i agree that you should be able 2 put some 1 bac if they miss and the is no advantage 2 u